Education Is Too Important to Leave Unchanged — Post 2, here is Post 1.

Educational equity is a worthy goal. Every child deserves opportunities to learn, develop their potential, and thrive.

But equity has become largely synonymous with getting children to achieve similar standardized test scores in reading and mathematics. Those who fall behind must catch up.

Governments have invested billions. Researchers have conducted thousands of studies. Schools have implemented countless interventions. Yet gaps persist.

PISA 2022 found that socioeconomic gaps in mathematics remained statistically unchanged over a decade in 42 of 62 education systems with comparable data. In the United States, NAEP shows that the performance gap between fourth-grade readers at the 90th and 10th percentiles widened from 91 points in 1992 to 107 in 2024.

Perhaps we should ask: Can a system designed to standardize, rank, and select children ever eliminate achievement gaps?

Children enter school with different experiences, strengths, and opportunities. We expect them to achieve the same outcomes at approximately the same ages, label differences deficiencies, and prescribe interventions. Yet we continue using achievement differences to sort students and distribute opportunities.

We define the gaps, attempt to close them, and depend on them to determine who gets ahead.

Consider America’s preoccupation with early reading.

Reading matters. But children from disadvantaged families may enter school with fewer opportunities to develop conventional literacy, even while possessing valuable capabilities in other areas. Those missing age-based benchmarks receive additional instruction and remediation. In some states, third graders who fail reading requirements can be retained.

Such policies are often justified by research linking early reading proficiency to later success. One widely cited study found that 16% of children not proficient in third-grade reading failed to graduate on time, compared with 4% of proficient readers.

But poverty tells another story. Among proficient readers who experienced poverty, 11% failed to graduate on time, compared with 9% of nonproficient readers who had never experienced poverty.

What if we have mistaken an indicator of socioeconomic disadvantage for the underlying problem?

Socioeconomic circumstances shape both early reading achievement and later life opportunities. Improving reading scores alone cannot eliminate these inequalities. Worse, using reading scores to restrict advancement risks turning existing disadvantages into additional educational barriers.

And there is another trap: Time is finite, even if human possibilities are not.

Every additional hour of compulsory decoding drills or remediation that replaces other educational experiences is an hour unavailable for science, art, meaningful projects, or discovering talents.

An excessive focus on reading also consumes educational resources—funding, teacher time, professional development, and institutional energy—that could otherwise create diverse learning opportunities.

As a consequence, we may be exhausting the very resources that could help disadvantaged children excel in other areas.

We could narrow measured reading gaps while widening unmeasured gaps in creativity, confidence, agency, and talent development. Excessive remediation may even diminish children’s desire to read.

We measure the gaps we try to close, but not the gaps we may be creating.

Whether intended or not, this arrangement risks keeping disadvantaged children busy correcting deficiencies while more privileged peers develop capabilities beyond the tested curriculum.

In From Deficiency to Strength (2016) and What Works May Hurt (2018), I challenged deficit-driven education and warned that interventions improving targeted outcomes may sacrifice other dimensions of development.

Perhaps policymakers, researchers, educators, and parents have all become trapped in a quagmire of short-term outcomes in a handful of subjects, losing sight of education’s long-term purpose.

Equity is not making every child equally good at the same things. It is giving every child the opportunity to become great in their own way.

Instead of asking only which achievement gaps we are closing, we should ask which human possibilities we are closing off.


For Readers Who Want to Explore Further

Zhao, Y. (2016). From deficiency to strength: Shifting the mindset about education inequality. Journal of Social Issues, 72(4), 720–739.

https://doi.org/10.1111/josi.12191

Zhao, Y. (2018). What works may hurt: Side effects in education. Teachers College Press.

Data Sources

OECD. (2023). PISA 2022 results (Volume I): The state of learning and equity in education.

https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/pisa-2022-results-volume-i_53f23881-en/full-report/long-term-trends-in-performance-and-equity-in-education_d66743ab.html

National Center for Education Statistics. (2025). The Nation’s Report Card: 2024 reading assessment.

https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reports/reading/2024/g4_8/national-trends/?grade=4

Hernandez, D. J. (2011). Double jeopardy: How third-grade reading skills and poverty influence high school graduation. Annie E. Casey Foundation.

https://www.aecf.org/resources/double-jeopardy

Whinnery, E., & Weyer, M. (2024). Early grade literacy: Is third grade retention effective? Education Commission of the States.

https://www.ecs.org/early-grade-literacy-is-third-grade-retention-effective

More about Yong Zhao

Dr. Yong Zhao is a Foundation Distinguished Professor in the School of Education at the University of Kansas. He previously served as the Presidential Chair, Associate Dean, and Director of the Institute for Global and Online Education in the College of Education, University of Oregon, where he was also a Professor in the Department of Educational Measurement, Policy, and Leadership. Prior to Oregon, Yong Zhao was University Distinguished Professor at the College of Education, Michigan State University, where he also served as the founding director of the Center for Teaching and Technology, executive director of the Confucius Institute, as well as the US-China Center for Research on Educational Excellence. Additionally, he worked as a professor of educational leadership in the Faculty of Education at University of Melbourne and senior researcher at the Mitchell Institute of Victoria University in Australia. He was a visiting Global Professor at University of Bath and a visiting scholar at Warwick University in the UK.

Most Recent Articles on AI and Education